Following a post on X, AMD Japan's claim that the company values gamers "above all else" saw those gamers point out that its own CEO believes the company is more focused on data centers.
I’m out of the loop, what did AMD do wrong? Other than enriching themselves into the AI bubble of course. I thought AMD was still a lot better than Nvidia in any case.
Meanwhile everybody has seemingly forgotten how groundbreaking the Ryzen platform was/is. Everybody thought Intel and Xeon was unstoppable until Ryzen came out and Epyc ate Intel’s lunch to the point that they’re nearly irrelevant. I literally have a desktop motherboard running an AMD Pro APU with ECC for a NAS that uses like 50W of power at load - it can’t really be overstated how unthinkable that was a decade ago or how wildly expensive/power hungry it would have been to do that on an Intel mobo (if you could even run it at a desktop form factor and not on a server blade). Also the fact that each new generation has largely been backwards compatible and doesn’t force new mobo or hardware upgrades to leverage improvements is extremely nice.
Nvidia has a lot bigger head start on AMD in a lot of ways because they only really started shaking the cobwebs off like 10-12 years ago. But they also are developing GPU capabilities pretty steadily and ROCm is picking up steam and also AMD consistently develops OSS drivers/tooling and also supports Linux natively to the point that amdgpu on Linux oftentimes performs better than the Radeon drivers on Windows. People want so badly to pile on hate but medium/long-term stuff Lisa Su has done has really been to the benefit of both enterprise and hobbyist consumers.
I don’t think Intel’s mismanagement is solely what caused AMD to produce a genuinely better platform that has compatibility across server/desktop. Their mismanagement enabled AMD to take over those spaces very quickly but it was genuinely good engineering that let the timing of Intel being complacent working out in their favor.
The GPU space is a completely different competitive landscape. My only point was that up to this point AMD under Lisa Su’s leadership has been a much better company overall. I think they are genuinely working on improving their graphics stacks to be competitive with Nvidia but there’s a much larger gap to close, but now that they have largely captured the CPU server space they can focus on building out GPU capabilities but it’s going to take time. I’m merely trying to dispel the GPs point that it’s some kind of conspiratorial plot by AMD to deliberately be bad or something by pointing out there’s a decade long track record to the contrary (at least for now).
Behind would excuse poor performance. But Intel with it’s cheap Arc and Battlemage GPUs were seen as real competition and flew off shelves even though they were inferior. A shame those got quietly canceled before the line actually matured.
Competition is supposed to bring better value to the customer. We’re obviously not the customer if they see a price increase by their competitor as a good reason to set a higher price. People are connecting dots with the close ties the two CEOs had, but I don’t personally believe that has anything to do with it. I believe AMD just likes the extra cash brought in by matching price increases.
AMD abandoned gamers and hasn’t innovated jack shit in the consumer space in forever. All while claiming they’re gamer first. All while being Nvidia - $50 since forever.
They’re just Little Nvidia and nothing more. No soul, no passion, no respect for any of the consumers.
Just like Nvidia.
If you need more than that to hate something, you’re horribly naive.
I’m out of the loop, what did AMD do wrong? Other than enriching themselves into the AI bubble of course. I thought AMD was still a lot better than Nvidia in any case.
Refusing to compete. They do everything lockstep with Nvidia, they are just worse at it.
Meanwhile everybody has seemingly forgotten how groundbreaking the Ryzen platform was/is. Everybody thought Intel and Xeon was unstoppable until Ryzen came out and Epyc ate Intel’s lunch to the point that they’re nearly irrelevant. I literally have a desktop motherboard running an AMD Pro APU with ECC for a NAS that uses like 50W of power at load - it can’t really be overstated how unthinkable that was a decade ago or how wildly expensive/power hungry it would have been to do that on an Intel mobo (if you could even run it at a desktop form factor and not on a server blade). Also the fact that each new generation has largely been backwards compatible and doesn’t force new mobo or hardware upgrades to leverage improvements is extremely nice.
Nvidia has a lot bigger head start on AMD in a lot of ways because they only really started shaking the cobwebs off like 10-12 years ago. But they also are developing GPU capabilities pretty steadily and ROCm is picking up steam and also AMD consistently develops OSS drivers/tooling and also supports Linux natively to the point that amdgpu on Linux oftentimes performs better than the Radeon drivers on Windows. People want so badly to pile on hate but medium/long-term stuff Lisa Su has done has really been to the benefit of both enterprise and hobbyist consumers.
Zen’s neat, sure, but let’s not forget that Intel’s mismanagement has contributed a lot to AMDs success.
I don’t think Intel’s mismanagement is solely what caused AMD to produce a genuinely better platform that has compatibility across server/desktop. Their mismanagement enabled AMD to take over those spaces very quickly but it was genuinely good engineering that let the timing of Intel being complacent working out in their favor.
The GPU space is a completely different competitive landscape. My only point was that up to this point AMD under Lisa Su’s leadership has been a much better company overall. I think they are genuinely working on improving their graphics stacks to be competitive with Nvidia but there’s a much larger gap to close, but now that they have largely captured the CPU server space they can focus on building out GPU capabilities but it’s going to take time. I’m merely trying to dispel the GPs point that it’s some kind of conspiratorial plot by AMD to deliberately be bad or something by pointing out there’s a decade long track record to the contrary (at least for now).
What is making people say they are “refusing to compete” rather than “behind”?
Behind would excuse poor performance. But Intel with it’s cheap Arc and Battlemage GPUs were seen as real competition and flew off shelves even though they were inferior. A shame those got quietly canceled before the line actually matured.
No, it’s that AMD has matched Nvidia’s price increases for a while now.
Competition is supposed to bring better value to the customer. We’re obviously not the customer if they see a price increase by their competitor as a good reason to set a higher price. People are connecting dots with the close ties the two CEOs had, but I don’t personally believe that has anything to do with it. I believe AMD just likes the extra cash brought in by matching price increases.
People just want something to hate. This article is about amd, so it must be hated.
AMD abandoned gamers and hasn’t innovated jack shit in the consumer space in forever. All while claiming they’re gamer first. All while being Nvidia - $50 since forever.
They’re just Little Nvidia and nothing more. No soul, no passion, no respect for any of the consumers.
Just like Nvidia.
If you need more than that to hate something, you’re horribly naive.
I don’t put as much energy into these companies as you do. Thank you for the response though. I appreciate it.
“I’m better because I don’t care” ok buddy
That’s not what I said, but good try.
Why does everything need to be an argument on here. It’s annoying.