Matrix is not really much of a viable alternative to Discord in the way that you present it. For e.g. one big barrier is a lack of RBAC in the spec (https://spec.matrix.org/v1.19/client-server-api/#mroompower_levels) having power_level mirror classic IRC style permissions isn’t really flexible enough to provide the same behavior you get from a Discord server. It would be awesome if you had the ability to have a m.space and provide different permissions to child objects or assign roles so that you can opt into seeing particular text channels similar to how larger/well-organized Discord servers work.
The fragmentation across clients is also still a pretty big sticking point. Some of the more popular clients still don’t support spaces (like you mention) and threads which introduces a lot of friction. Also the entire way that e2ee works when you want to use >1 device is pretty much a nonstarter for any casual user which kind of defeats a lot of the points of using Matrix to begin with.
There’s also historically (not sure if it’s still an issue because I’ve largely detached myself from Matrix development after Element went all-in on supporting government sectors as their primary demographic) been problems of Synapse implementing experimental features before the MSCs are fully ratified which created churn across homeservers and oftentime left you with limited choice but to use Synapse which carries its own set of annoyances because of how heavyweight and sometimes difficult it is to administer.
I’d love for Matrix to succeed and I’ve been rooting for and using it for a decade, but at this point I’m not so sure it’s actually going to happen and have largely resigned to the “maybe all the IRC v3 and XMPP people have been right all along” camp.
Matrix is not really much of a viable alternative to Discord in the way that you present it.
Sorry to be a bit off-topic, but since you seem to be very knowledgeable on the subject: Do you think there are any good replacements for Discord? In particular, I’d define the core functionality as group and direct messaging and voice/video calls, although sever/channels equivalents, more advanced management features, ect. would be a big bonus.
Not immediately off-hand. I’ve been eyeing a few of the newer ones that seem promising like Fluxer, Stoat, etc. but haven’t deployed any of them. Ultimately I mostly just still use my matrix.org account and think I’m largely settling on hosting xmpp for friends because ejabberd is trivial to deploy and Movim (https://movim.eu/) seems like a pretty mature client atp and supports a lot of the features that someone who wants to migrate off Discord would want.
I imagine the landscape might continue to develop but ultimately self-hosting a service comparable to Discord isn’t easy and people genuinely want to flock onto the thing that just works or has the lowest barrier to entry.
Matrix is not really much of a viable alternative to Discord in the way that you present it. For e.g. one big barrier is a lack of RBAC in the spec (https://spec.matrix.org/v1.19/client-server-api/#mroompower_levels) having power_level mirror classic IRC style permissions isn’t really flexible enough to provide the same behavior you get from a Discord server. It would be awesome if you had the ability to have a
m.spaceand provide different permissions to child objects or assign roles so that you can opt into seeing particular text channels similar to how larger/well-organized Discord servers work.The fragmentation across clients is also still a pretty big sticking point. Some of the more popular clients still don’t support spaces (like you mention) and threads which introduces a lot of friction. Also the entire way that e2ee works when you want to use >1 device is pretty much a nonstarter for any casual user which kind of defeats a lot of the points of using Matrix to begin with.
There’s also historically (not sure if it’s still an issue because I’ve largely detached myself from Matrix development after Element went all-in on supporting government sectors as their primary demographic) been problems of Synapse implementing experimental features before the MSCs are fully ratified which created churn across homeservers and oftentime left you with limited choice but to use Synapse which carries its own set of annoyances because of how heavyweight and sometimes difficult it is to administer.
I’d love for Matrix to succeed and I’ve been rooting for and using it for a decade, but at this point I’m not so sure it’s actually going to happen and have largely resigned to the “maybe all the IRC v3 and XMPP people have been right all along” camp.
Sorry to be a bit off-topic, but since you seem to be very knowledgeable on the subject: Do you think there are any good replacements for Discord? In particular, I’d define the core functionality as group and direct messaging and voice/video calls, although sever/channels equivalents, more advanced management features, ect. would be a big bonus.
Not immediately off-hand. I’ve been eyeing a few of the newer ones that seem promising like Fluxer, Stoat, etc. but haven’t deployed any of them. Ultimately I mostly just still use my matrix.org account and think I’m largely settling on hosting xmpp for friends because ejabberd is trivial to deploy and Movim (https://movim.eu/) seems like a pretty mature client atp and supports a lot of the features that someone who wants to migrate off Discord would want.
I imagine the landscape might continue to develop but ultimately self-hosting a service comparable to Discord isn’t easy and people genuinely want to flock onto the thing that just works or has the lowest barrier to entry.