cross-posted from: https://lemmy.world/post/42657201
I’m struggling to replicate some window behavior I’m used to (from Windows) on a new install. Does anyone have any insight?
My goal is to play a game full screen but still be able to pin windows above it.
If a game is set to Full Screen, “Keep Above Others” doesn’t work.
If I run a game Full Screen (Windowed), it keeps the taskbar visible and gives me cropped resolution options.
The only way I’ve found that works is manually configuring each window property to turn off the title bar, set a fixed position, and a minimum resolution. And also setting the taskbar to Auto Hide.
I don’t want to manually configure every game (which often requires restarting it multiple times). I don’t want my taskbar to Auto Hide. And I want it to be hidden until I alt+tab or press the start key.
Is this possible?
there’s a shortcut for setting overlay depth, i don’t remember if its the default but for me meta+scroll on a window will push a window back or bring to the top.
if I’m in borderless full screen i can select what i want to overlay on my game by scrolling it to the top and demoting the game window to mid by one. note other windows may overlay that are open so its best to minimize or close anything else.
How did you set scroll as a shortcut? I found the option but it doesn’t accept scrolling as an input
Either way, this has the same effect as Keep Below where ALL windows stay above the game. And still requires hiding the taskbar which I’m really trying to avoid - if for no other reason than it pops up any time my mouse gets near the bottom of the screen
i had to double check its
settings - window management - window behavior - window action - at the bottom you can set mouse wheel to ‘keep above/below’
what launch options are you using on games? i haven’t had this issue using proton + native wayland launch options. iirc gamescope treats windowed apps differently because its only a container and doesn’t understand the diff between windowed and borderless windowed
testing in baldurs gate 3, no launch arguments, this works in both borderless windowed and full screen for me without taskbar popping up. though clicking on the window sitting above in fullscreen minimizes and in borderless i have to click back in to regain mouse control. basically the overlay can steal focus, maybe a kwin rule on the overlay to prevent focus stealing might work?
Set the game to always below and the app to always above.
Use borderless window in games. Avoid full screen it’s jank as fuck basically always.
Borderless window keeps the taskbar visible and the vertical resolution is cropped to match
Out of my ass I would say that this has to do with kde trying to optimize the full screen window by skipping compositing for it (direct scan-out, useful for e.g. gaming), of course this is not possible to do with windows on top (they have to be composited). I would have expected KDE to disable direct scan-out once you put windows on top, but maybe it doesn’t.
I recommend posting this to KDE’s bugzilla, they should get in touch pretty quickly for something like this, of course recognizing and solving the issue are two entirely different things.
But before posting, I’d suggest you do a test: you can disable direct scan-out globally by going on “display settings” and unchecking “screen tearing: allow in fullscreen windows”. Try and see if the issue goes away. And make sure to mention this test and the result on the bugzilla post.
I will get that out tonight, thank you! I am more than willing to lose some FPS by comping the game.
I didn’t realize screen tearing was even enabled by default. Will I be limited on refresh rate? My display is 165hz
You will not be limited, as long as you enabled 165hz in the settings. Tho, you might experience some minor latency, at most one frame, but you really shouldn’t, it depends. I would say that at 165hz, one frame of latency is not that much.
Also the compositor tearing option is there to allow the game to skip v-syncing and cause tearing. But, if the compositor allows tearing, and the game implements vsync, it will not tear. Actually, having both vsync in the game and tearing disabled in the compositor could cause more latency, but it depends, it might not.
Edit: I first said you should try what other comments said, but then I saw you already replied to them
Also, you said you are willing to lose some FPS by compositing the game to have windows on top. I want to make clear that you cannot have windows on top of the game without compositing. This is not a Linux/KDE/Wayland thing, it’s just that compositing is the process that draws the windows. If this were an XBOX, so running a gaming-specific version of Windows on custom gaming specific hardware, it would still need to do compositing to draw a window on top of the game. Only something fullscreen can skip compositing, because at that point there’s only one window to draw without any positioning or shading necessary. But compositing is done per display, so you could put those windows in a second monitor and still skip compositing the game.
Turns out it was turned off by default. I tried it both ways to no avail.
I can alt+tab and the window shows up above the game (until I click back into the game) so it’s obviously capable of it. Windows also have no issues displaying above the game when I have the game set to Keep Below Others.
I have no technical knowledge on how this works but it seems like “Keep Above Others” isn’t actually moving it to the top layer.
Well, then I’d say that’s a bug report alright
Window Rules should allow you to do this
This is what I am using but nothing trumps Full Screen and Full Screen Window keeps the taskbar
