Are you saying they should go back to Steam Greenlight, back before then?
That Steam/Valve should manually human review an entire publishing/listing agreement for every applicant?
If you wanna destroy the video gaming indie scene, that’d be how you’d do that. You’d be cutting away 95%-99% of games published per year.
Valve only has like 300 employees doing everything that Valve does. They build layers and layers of processes and automated testing and sorting and flagging and categorizing so that they don’t have to subcontract out 4,000 people in basically a call center somewhere, its the same reason the steam ‘forums’ are notoriously a wretched hive of scum and villainy.
A human only ever gets involved when something has seriously tripped a bunch of red flags in a fairly uncommon, or new and novel way.
It would probably be a good excercise for just anybody to scroll through that site, see how there are different kinds of AI use, some are arguably more justifiable than others (indie game translating text for localization vs AAA game generating entire seasonal update of micropurchasable cosmetics, etc), and that you almost certainly own at least one game that does have some amount of AI in it or involved in making it, if you bought literally any game in the last 3 years.
Or, you could maybe use GoG, who … actually do the old handpicked curation thing, and do it pretty damned well, imo.
While I do think that it would be better for curation to be 3rd party and not done by valve choosing which games live or die, I also think that if you have a service that you’re scaling up, you should hire the support staff such a service would require. Valve can certainly afford to hire more than 300 people.
But that defeats the entire way that Steam is designed. It is meant to accept all comers, who meet guidelines, and be the video gaming everything store. Thats… the entire strategy.
Valve doesn’t choose what games live or die. The… the players do. The whole way Steam works is by crowdsourcing reviews and descriptions and such, thats what powers its ‘algorithm’. Now sure, this system isn’t perfect… but its like the core idea of Steam, that its a kind of psuedo democracy… the player base are the curators, not some editorial board of 10ish people.
There are tons of different ways to search for games by different kinds of filters and such… I’ll give you that some of them aren’t super useful for everyone, but you can dial down to a pretty niche set of traits you want in a game, if you wanna be particular.
Steam has curators. It has a whole system for curators, for becoming one, for following one… there’s nothing stopping you from becoming a curator, if you can’t find any you think are good.
Steam can afford to subcontract out to a call center, yes. But they want to keep their operation small and local, in line with their flat hierarchy/voluntary clique form of getting things done, that is rather unique as a business culture / ‘management’ style.
Throw on a bunch of subcontractors, it breaks that, its diamtetrically opposed to it.
And also… they don’t need to hire more people, if they continue to have a small number of the most competent people in the industry, continue being very clever in designing systems that automate the mind numbing busy work you’d otherwise have contractors doing.
You’re asking Steam to stop being Steam. GoG exists if you want a well curated game market place thats like what you say you want.
… Again?
Are you saying they should go back to Steam Greenlight, back before then?
That Steam/Valve should manually human review an entire publishing/listing agreement for every applicant?
If you wanna destroy the video gaming indie scene, that’d be how you’d do that. You’d be cutting away 95%-99% of games published per year.
Valve only has like 300 employees doing everything that Valve does. They build layers and layers of processes and automated testing and sorting and flagging and categorizing so that they don’t have to subcontract out 4,000 people in basically a call center somewhere, its the same reason the steam ‘forums’ are notoriously a wretched hive of scum and villainy.
A human only ever gets involved when something has seriously tripped a bunch of red flags in a fairly uncommon, or new and novel way.
https://gameaicheck.com/
Also that exists.
It would probably be a good excercise for just anybody to scroll through that site, see how there are different kinds of AI use, some are arguably more justifiable than others (indie game translating text for localization vs AAA game generating entire seasonal update of micropurchasable cosmetics, etc), and that you almost certainly own at least one game that does have some amount of AI in it or involved in making it, if you bought literally any game in the last 3 years.
Or, you could maybe use GoG, who … actually do the old handpicked curation thing, and do it pretty damned well, imo.
Steam makes so much net profit they could hire a 50 person crew to review new submissions and the cost would barely be a rounding error.
Would they? Probably not.
The irony of https://gameaicheck.com/ being developed by AI and using AI to determine of a game is AI 😅
Every anti-AI solution to AI created problems these days is centered on getting AI to fight AI. It’s going to be a glorious cyberpunk future.
Theoretically it takes one to know one, I suppose, hahaha!
While I do think that it would be better for curation to be 3rd party and not done by valve choosing which games live or die, I also think that if you have a service that you’re scaling up, you should hire the support staff such a service would require. Valve can certainly afford to hire more than 300 people.
But that defeats the entire way that Steam is designed. It is meant to accept all comers, who meet guidelines, and be the video gaming everything store. Thats… the entire strategy.
Valve doesn’t choose what games live or die. The… the players do. The whole way Steam works is by crowdsourcing reviews and descriptions and such, thats what powers its ‘algorithm’. Now sure, this system isn’t perfect… but its like the core idea of Steam, that its a kind of psuedo democracy… the player base are the curators, not some editorial board of 10ish people.
There are tons of different ways to search for games by different kinds of filters and such… I’ll give you that some of them aren’t super useful for everyone, but you can dial down to a pretty niche set of traits you want in a game, if you wanna be particular.
Steam has curators. It has a whole system for curators, for becoming one, for following one… there’s nothing stopping you from becoming a curator, if you can’t find any you think are good.
Steam can afford to subcontract out to a call center, yes. But they want to keep their operation small and local, in line with their flat hierarchy/voluntary clique form of getting things done, that is rather unique as a business culture / ‘management’ style.
Throw on a bunch of subcontractors, it breaks that, its diamtetrically opposed to it.
And also… they don’t need to hire more people, if they continue to have a small number of the most competent people in the industry, continue being very clever in designing systems that automate the mind numbing busy work you’d otherwise have contractors doing.
You’re asking Steam to stop being Steam. GoG exists if you want a well curated game market place thats like what you say you want.